Dom as Merry or Charlie?

[Lostw/houtPBandJ]

:D I do like LOTR, but I like him better as Charlie. How about you?

[Marystat]

I love him as both...the characters DO have some similiarities but still they are totally different ones. They are both adorable :D

[Dom3654]

Tough choice...I like them both, but I'm going to say Charlie.

[liliana]

i like him as Charlie better Merry was cool but I definitely like him as Charlie better

[Eternally]

I like him better as Charlie. Though he was the cutest little thing as Merry!!! *pinches cheeks*

[Sway]

That's tough!! I'd say Charile, the grungy rocker *swoon* but I'm with Jamie, he's adorable as Merry! I'm just into stubble ;)

[Taru]

I like them both,but I like him better as Charlie.

[wilowren]

Love LOTR, books and movies. I think Dom as Charlie stands out more than Dom as Merry. The character of Charlie has had more of a chance with more time to develop.

[taelia]

thats a tough choice... i loved him as merry and i love him as charlie... but hmmm ill have to say charlie... i just love that caracter...

[Hollywood]

Charlie All The Way!!!

Although l do have to admit he was the hottest little hobbit. :)

[sawyer'sgirl]

i'm gonna go out there and say MERRY! i luved Lotr before Lost and i still love LOTR more. his character and cutness as merry made me want to watch lost and i wasn't let down. Charlie is awesome and cute and a rocker still...but i'm gonna have to go with the Hobbit!

[crow]

I have to say Charlie. Dom was great in LOTR but I like his character better in Lost! :)

[lunakasha]

Definitely Charlie....and especially as DOM!!! :lotsalove:

I always thought Charlie was adorable....but when I saw Dom on Jimmy Kimmel Live, I just wanted to JUMP him!!! :eek: hehehe

:D Luna/DB

[JaterLove]

CHarlie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Zarina]

You guys are so mean for making me choose :thud:

Lord of the Rings trilogie are my alltime favorite movies, and I just love the hobbits. BUT I gotta be honest. My fav was and will always be Pip, quickly followed by Merry and Sam.

Now Lost and with that character of Charlie has gotten me totally addicted to Dom, so in that way I should thank Charlie :D

[charlierocks]

I have to say that his role as Charlie is well played and so was Merry but I think he does better as Charlie. So I say Charlie. :)

[cemetrygatecrash]

Charlie's a rock star so that decided it for me.

[Pie]

Charlie, or course. :)

[Zack]

Charlie..

I hated Lord of the Rings..

Trilogy was soooooooo..... boring..

:)

[Lostw/houtPBandJ]

Thanks for posting guys!! :D Charlie Rules!!

[Meli]

Charlie of course :D I've never really seen him act as Merry anyway...

[realityshowhater]

MERRY! Merry, my dear Meriadoc that got me into Lost in the first place! Charlie's sweet, funny, cute, and to top it off, a bassist, but I still gotta go Merry. There was Merry and Pippin before Charlie and Claire, two perfect duos, but one is slightly perfecter.